Main image
20th November
2008
written by Aylad MacOdys

I want to preface this post with a couple of disclaimers.  First, understand that it’s a rant.  Matthew Dryden challenged people to write angrily and “with abandon” this week, and although this didn’t come out as angry as it could have, it’s more aggressive than I normally would get.  Blame him; he says it’s ok.

Second, as I was casting about for a topic for my rant, I serendipitously discovered a contest Word Sell, Inc. regarding cell phone use and abuse.  Now, I’m not a huge contest person, but there was a cash prize offered, and I did need a rant topic, so…

“Sir, cell phones are prohibited to students.”

...sigh...

...sigh...

He looks at me, and I can tell that if he were half — rather than twice — my age, his lower lip would be trembling.

“But what if there’s an emergency?” he almost wails.  “How will I get in touch with my son?”

“There is an emergency,” I respond.  “Your son’s grades are on life-support, and by texting in class, he’s pulling the plug.  Oh, and we have…” I pause to count on my fingers… “three land lines here at the school.  Your tax dollars at work, and all that, you know.  If you need to get in touch with your son for any reason, well, use your imagination.”

*cough*

Ok, so this scenario didn’t happen, but it could, and it might.  I have lectured parents considerably older than me about their child’s cell phone abuse.  Sometimes they don’t react well.  I can’t remember the last time that bothered me.

The real problem lies with the parents’ ignorance of and apathy toward the phones they buy and pay for.  Cell phone use can easily be monitored online; parents could, if they knew or cared, bestir themselves to check and see whether little Jenny is sending her boyfriend sweet nothings in the middle of Trigonometry.  Cell phone features can be opted-out by the person paying the bill; the girl in my Honors class who told me she’d run up a $700 bill through text messaging may have been the person at fault, but her parents could have stopped it before it happened.  Most effective is the one tactic parents seem least likely to use:

 Take away the bloomin’ phone!

It’s not an amputation.  It’s not child abuse, nor is it child neglect.  Remember little Miss Can’t-Stop-Texting?  She has her phone in her purse right now (unless she’s texting, which she probably is).  Seven hundred Washingtons isn’t enough to convince you that your so-called “social butterfly” (we used a different expression when I was a teen) can’t use a phone responsibly?  I bought my last computer for less than that!

For me, it’s irritating when any student checks their phone in class.  It’s frustrating when they try to use it during active instructional time.  It’s downright insulting that my Honors students, who claim to want to excel, whose parents claim that they’re sooo smart, prioritize their social lives above anything else.

And you know what else?  It’s worrying.  Parents who don’t understand how to monitor their teens’ cell phone use obviously don’t understand why they should.  Ignorance of technology is unfortunate and, for me, hard to understand… but it is at least not dangerous.  Ignorance of twenty-first-century teen texting tendencies could end up wrecking a child’s future – in more ways than one.

You’re gonna want your very own ring, so all your friends will know that you’re the one ruining the movie. — Ed Helms

(Photo Credit and License)
Spread the lies!
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
12 Comments
  1. 11/20/2008

    Hi Aylad, Thank you for joining in on our contest. This is an excellent rant in my opinion - certainly a topic worth ranting about. Reading your post, it occurs to me that since parents are ignoring their responsibilities, perhaps public schools should step in and offer courses in the ABC’s of cell phone behavior. Or perhaps offer an adult program on parenting.

  2. 11/20/2008

    From my understanding, if you’re an 11-year-old in London without a cell phone, then you’re not cool. I’ll be the first to advocate for a global community - but I agree with you on this matter.

    However…a cell phone is like a cancerous limb that should be cut away - by force, if need be.

    Fantastic rant. I hope someone sues me over this.

  3. 11/20/2008

    Brad: Thanks! I appreciate the opportunity to enter the contest and to share my rant with your readers. I hadn’t run into Word Sell, Inc. before, but now that I’ve read a few posts, I’m adding you to my feed reader.

    I wish my school could at least offer a workshop for parents showcasing all the monitoring tools and parental controls cell phone providers offer. I think (as you suggested) one of the main problems is ignorance.

    Then, of course, the parents attending the workshop would miss half of it by answering their phones. I have actually had entire parent conferences take place in 30-second segments in between the parents — not the students! — taking calls and sending text messages.

    Matthew: When I was 11, I was banned from even using the landline. It is sad but not surprising that preteens use unsupervised 24-hour telephone access as a status symbol. I hate to think what monsters we are raising.

  4. 11/21/2008

    If a child’s cellphone every rings during one of my lessons, I think I’d flip out. Then I’d be labelled as a dinosaur who doesn’t get it. But I like how the teacher reacted in this scenario.

    Cell phones are not a necessity. I don’t understand why people want to be immediately accessible everywhere they go. I sure don’t.

  5. 11/21/2008

    Yeah, smart-aleck, obnoxious, disrespectful, lazy, and mis-prioritized teens are one thing. I mean, I chose to teach this age group, and I knew what I was getting into.

    What really gets to me is the smugness parents can have when they take the position that I don’t have the right to take a child’s phone away, or the spinelessness with which they refuse to take it away themselves. Chase, you and I may be in the minority for believing that cell phones aren’t necessities.

    Thanks for stopping by! I hope to see you here again.

  6. Trina
    11/21/2008

    Great topic to rant on, well done. What a great mix, self indulgence, and indulgent parents…. There are so many aspects of cell phone dependancy that are so, so, wrong.

  7. 11/21/2008

    Agreed. To be fair, I occasionally post drafts of future posts by cell phone. But that’s not dependency, it’s convenience. …Right? :)

  8. Trina
    11/21/2008

    Re: convenience. Who are you trying to convince? ;-) I am sure no one is truly dependant on their cellphone, they just really, really, really need it…

  9. 11/22/2008

    Yep. I can quit anytime I want. Really.

  10. [...] Robyn McMaster, Kickstart Cellphone Smarts!* Jackie Cameron, Why I both love and hate mobile phones Aylad MacOdys, Hang. Up. Now. Kate Baggott, Your Mobile: More Expensive than You Know Brad Shorr, Cell Hell In [...]